J.Kilb at gmx.de
Sat Sep 2 21:10:49 CEST 2006
> Hi Juergen,
> > it seems that the ADT7475 is compatible with an ADT7463, so i have tried
> > to use the lm85 driver. (The ADT7475 is missing the Vid Inputs.)
> How did you figure out? I guess you mean the "vin inputs"? VID inputs
> are something different. Oh well, they are also missing, anyway.
I have found that the lm85 driver is usable for the ADT7463, then i thought
there could be a possibility that the ADT7475 is compatible with the ADT7463
in some way.
After that i have compared nearly every page of the two datasheets....
If you take a look at the functional diagram of the ADT7463
you can see in the upper left corner 7 "VID" Inputs which are not available at
> Replace ":" with "=", and it should work better, except that according
> to the output below, the proper address is 1,0x2e rather than 0,0x2e.
> Do the fan speeds reported here match the ones displayed by your BIOS?
> Can you try setting limits and checking whether alarms trigger as they
Yes they do.. i think good enough ;-)
CHA_FAN2 1427 1420 (fan2)
CHA_FAN3 1908 1889 (fan3)
CHA_FAN4 1978 2019 (CPU_FAN)
> The temp2 value is rather frightening... It is supposed to be the
> chip's own temperature. It looks like the chip supports different modes,
> include an "ADT7463 compatibility mode", and I guess your chip is not
> in this mode, thus the weird reading. The external temperatures are
> obviously not wired.
> Now the question is, do we want to add support for the ADT7475 chip to
> the lm85 driver? That's a recurring question, each time several chips
> are compatible but still somewhat different.
> In this case, the lm85 driver already supports 6 different chips
> (although there was no reason to differenciate between the B and C
> revisions as far as I can see) and we must beware of not increasing the
> complexity of our drivers beyond reason. I'm not too sure what to do.
> Maybe we can try adding support to the lm85 driver, and if it turns up
> adding too much complexity, do a separate driver.
Yes i think, this would be the right way.
> One element which may help us decide is whether the ADT7475 itself is
> compatible with other chips. If it is, making a new driver for the
> ADT7475 and the compatible chips would make sense. Can you make some
Yes i can do some research... but i've not much spare time at the moment and i
am on vacation for 3 weeks starting next friday.
More information about the lm-sensors